corsasport.co.uk
 

Corsa Sport » Message Board » Help Zone, Modification and ICE Advice » 1.2 Vs 1.7 DTI » Post Reply

Post Reply
Who Can Post? All users can post new topics and all users can reply.
Icon:
Formatting Mode:
Normal
Advanced
Help

Insert Bold text Insert Italicized text Insert Underlined text Insert Centered text Insert a Hyperlink Insert Email Hyperlink Insert an Image Insert Code Formatted text Insert Quoted text
Message:
HTML is Off
Smilies are On
BB Code is On
[img] Code is On
Post Options: Disable smileys?
Turn BBCode off?
Receive email notification of new replies?

Kris TD

posted on 8th Mar 03 at 00:14

thats only a 10 bhp gain, not really very much for the 500 plus he would have spent on that sxi.
td's are gonna get very fast and have loads of tuning parts available in the next few years, u can alreay buy psycho stuff for the VAG td's.


Plymouth_Corsa

posted on 6th Mar 03 at 13:29

There was a silver Corsa C SXi 1200cc 16v in total vauxhall mag a few months ago, and it was in one of there rolling road features, was fitted with a chip, filter and full exhaust system and dyno'd@85bhp - thats better then a 8v SRi....so they can be tuned a bit more then standard, they are not too bad.


Foz

posted on 6th Mar 03 at 11:49

quote:
Originally posted by Cybermonkey24
CorsaFoz you are a dick.

Dave


thanks, quite mature fighting online.


Cybermonkey

posted on 5th Mar 03 at 09:07

Saying that though, TD's are very good when it comes to chipping. Just changing the timing levels for the turbo can see a whole lot more power and torque. I would say go with the diesel. They are a whole lot better nowadays. CorsaFoz you are a dick.

Dave


Kris TD

posted on 5th Mar 03 at 01:00

dump valve adds no power on td's
bleed valves are only really useful on old td's u need a rechip on newer td's


Paul_J

posted on 5th Mar 03 at 00:54

I think your all missing the other factors...

Tuning...

1.2 16v There's basically nothing that can be done... well cheaply anyway...

1.7 DTi - surely you can add a decent dump valve and bleed valve etc and get quite a lot of extra Bhp from it... Also you see bigger gains from mods like power chips on turbo based cars...

Paul J


Kris TD

posted on 5th Mar 03 at 00:48

that noise you here is the egr.
the dieselhas much quicker in gear times than the petrol, woul dsh1t on the 1.2 during normal driving.


Red_SXi

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 23:01

we shall beg to differ then. I'd be worried about selling it, because i know one thing for sure, i wouldn't want a second hand deisel corsa for shit. But they are becoming more popular now, so i dunno


Mikeboy

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 22:59

good point, but imo theres more reasons to get it over just fuel economy


Red_SXi

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 21:38

You get better economy, but the car costs £700 more, so to get your money back you have to do at least 20k miles a year, and it depreciates more in my opinion. Believe me its only worth having if you do lots of miles


Mikeboy

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 20:12

oh yeh, people complain about diesels being so noisey.

The only time I'd say the DTi sounds noisey is when its cold and its next to a wall or a building, but the rest of the time it sounds sweet - a nice manly purr


Mikeboy

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 20:09

I've got the DTi and Im well pleased with it :)

I've had it bout 2 months and Im still getting used to driving it properly. Maybe it's just me ! :boggle: but u need to remember when changing gear, not to shove ur foot back down on the accelerator, but rather wait til the clutch is right up, then bring the accelerator down ... or else u seem to lose bout 60% of the turbo-ness/quickess ... lol u can see I know what Im talking about :D

Yep - its great on fuel - I got over 400 miles on the tank even when it was runnning in.

And like black_corsa_sxi says, if u have ur window open, accelerating in 2nd say, turbo going 'schheeeeeeiiiiiiissssSSSS', - then into 3rd, and u hear a sexy little 'chhhhhh' sound before the new 'scheeeiissssssSS' :D Love it

Apparantly its got a better suspension set up (no longer "uprated and lowered") - but its different suspension - someone off here said it was better.

Like I say Im still getting used to it, only been driving bout 15 months, before i had an old noooova.

But sometimes when u pull away just right but not really expecting it, it pins u back in ur seat and knocks ur neck back ! Done that a few times .. . I might be exagerating a bit, but u'll see what I mean I hope .


Doug_SRi

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 19:50

1.7DTi is better, i drive the 1.2 at the moment and its shit in fuel.....my brother has the 1.7DTi and its a bit quicker i think....were getting the 1.7DTi SXi very soon tho but main reason i can give is the 1.2 is really bad on fuel:(


d0gz_bollox

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 17:14

the deisal will have more power at high speeds since it has a bigger displacement.


Geezer

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 17:03

15 miles the the gallon extra is alot. people still seem to think diesels are bad, the new ones are faily good now performance wise. and sound has got better as well.

but still petrol is better


Gambit

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 16:59

i would only buy a diesel if i done a lot of miles


Red_SXi

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 16:55

Well............. The deisel feels quicker to drive, and would impress the passengers more because they think they're going faster, but in a race they are about the same, the petrol is better for racing i'd sy cos the limiter don't kick in til 6,500 on the petrol, but the desiels kicks in at abuot 5000 u think. I'd buy a petrol unless i do over 30k a year.

Another thing with the deisel is that if you pull out of a junction onto un-even road surface and boot it in 1st it looses traction easier because of the torque, and i'd amagine handles slightly worse because of this plus the weight factor.


Geezer

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 16:45

quote:
Originally posted by black_corsa_sxi
I prefer the 1.2 because it sounds nicer, plus it is obviously more rev happy. I do have alot of fun driving my Dad's 1.7 Dti Sxi though, it has a kinda dump valve, you can only really hear it with the windows open.


any noticable speed difference?


Red_SXi

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 16:39

I prefer the 1.2 because it sounds nicer, plus it is obviously more rev happy. I do have alot of fun driving my Dad's 1.7 Dti Sxi though, it has a kinda dump valve, you can only really hear it with the windows open.


Geezer

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 16:28

well i asked because i want to know, i've got a 1.2 atm and am getting a 1.7 in a weeks time i woundered what people thought.


Foz

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 16:26

who actually cares!


Geezer

posted on 4th Mar 03 at 16:22

which will be better?

simlar speeds and 60mile to the gallon on a diesel so i'd go for diesel

this is the corsa C newest engines