corsasport.co.uk
 

Corsa Sport » Message Board » Help Zone, Modification and ICE Advice » C20xe cavalier as a donor instead of astra any problems? » Post Reply

Post Reply
Who Can Post? All users can post new topics and all users can reply.
Icon:
Formatting Mode:
Normal
Advanced
Help

Insert Bold text Insert Italicized text Insert Underlined text Insert Centered text Insert a Hyperlink Insert Email Hyperlink Insert an Image Insert Code Formatted text Insert Quoted text
Message:
HTML is Off
Smilies are On
BB Code is On
[img] Code is On
Post Options: Disable smileys?
Turn BBCode off?
Receive email notification of new replies?

tonydry

posted on 25th Aug 03 at 20:46

What engines are affected with porous heads?

It is claimed Vauxhall doesn't actual know the true figure of faulty heads there are out on the market. But the two main engines affected are the 2L 16v Double Over Head Cam (DOHC) 'red-top' engines, C20XE (2L 16v DOHC) and C20LET (2L 16v DOHC Turbo). These are found in the Astra GTE, Astra GSi, Cavalier 2L 16v, Cavalier Turbo, Calibra 2L 16v and Calibra Turbo. No other engines or cars were affected. So any 8v, SOHC, V6 or Ecotec engines are NOT affected by the problem.

The table below shows the years effected and the types of engines. The main culprit was the manufacture, there were two. Heads were either made by Cosworth (Coscast) or Kolben Schmidt (KS).


Supplier Year Vehicle Engine Type
Tensile strength Problem
(Coscast) Cosworth 1987-1989 KADETT-E C20XE 350N/mm˛ No Problem!
(KS)
Kolben Schmidt 1989-1991 KADETT-E C20XE 380N/mm˛ Water damage possible
(KS)
Kolben Schmidt 1989-1993 ASTRA-F
VECTRA-A
CALIBRA
C20XE
C20LET
380N/mm˛ Water damage possible
(Coscast) Cosworth 1993-199x ASTRA-F
VECTRA-A
CALIBRA
C20XE
C20LET
350N/mm˛ No Problem!
(KS)
Kolben Schmidt 1993-199x ASTRA-F
VECTRA-A
CALIBRA C20XE
C20LET
220N/mm˛ Material too soft!
Head screws come loose!


tonydry

posted on 25th Aug 03 at 20:31

sory but all turbos dident have coscast heads as standerd as i no several people with lets and only 1 has a coscast haed and he changed that as it was the gm 1 before he snaped a cam belt


miles

posted on 25th Aug 03 at 20:28

I didn't think so.....but maybe....


Gary GSi

posted on 25th Aug 03 at 20:07

Some of the early Calibras had coscast heads it think.


miles

posted on 25th Aug 03 at 19:56

All the turbo's have coscast heads as standard. IIRC only the astra gte's have them n/a


tonydry

posted on 25th Aug 03 at 19:42

the cavs do come with coscast heads as ive got 1 on my let dont think it made a diferance its just some have the coscast and some dont


miles

posted on 25th Aug 03 at 18:47

The engines are identical, although your not going to get a coscast head on a cavy. The exhaust manifolds are different i think, although finding a new one isn't hard (i have a astra gte 16v manifold in my garden! LOL) The looms are the same except for the length, due to different engine bay sizes and ecu positions.

No idea about the drive shafts, I wouldn't be suprised if they were the same though! You need EPC!


ainsley_brader

posted on 25th Aug 03 at 17:02

Are there any disadvantages for using a cav gsi as a donor rather than the astra.
I'm thinking with regards differences in exhaust manifolds, looms, driveshafts?

Beardy you posted how to modify std astra driveshafts can the same be said for cav driveshafts do you know?

Any help you can give me would be appreciated!

Ains :wave: